The Bow and the Lyre: A Platonic Reading of the Odyssey

By Seth Benardete

During this interesting interpretation of the Odyssey, the past due popular pupil Seth Benardete means that Homer can have been the 1st to philosophize in a Platonic feel. He argues that the Odyssey matters exactly the relation among philosophy and poetry and, extra greatly, the rational and the irrational in humans. In gentle of this probability, Bernardete works backward and forward from Homer to Plato to envision the relation among knowledge and justice and attempts to get well an unique knowing of philosophy that Plato, too, recovered through reflecting at the knowledge of the poet. At stake in his argument isn't any under the background of philosophy and the traditional knowing of poetry. The Bow and the Lyre is a booklet that each classicist and historian of philosophy must have.

Show description

Quick preview of The Bow and the Lyre: A Platonic Reading of the Odyssey PDF

Best Literary Criticism books

Lectures on Russian Literature

The author’s observations at the nice nineteenth-century Russian writers-Chekhov, Dostoevsky, Gogol, Gorky, Tolstoy, and Turgenev. “This quantity. .. by no means as soon as fails to teach and stimulate. it is a nice Russian conversing of serious Russians” (Anthony Burgess). Edited and with an advent via Fredson Bowers; illustrations.

Men in Dark Times

Essays on Karl Jaspers, Rosa Luxemburg, Pope John XXIII, Isak Dinesen, Bertolt Brecht, Randall Jarrell, and others whose lives and paintings illuminated the early a part of the century. Index.

Five Words: Critical Semantics in the Age of Shakespeare and Cervantes

Blood. Invention. Language. Resistance. global. 5 traditional phrases that do loads of conceptual paintings in lifestyle and literature. during this unique scan in serious semantics, Roland Greene considers how those 5 phrases replaced over the process the 16th century and what their alterations point out approximately broader forces in technological know-how, politics, and different disciplines.

How Literature Saved My Life

Mixing confessional feedback and cultural autobiography, David Shields explores the ability of literature to make lifestyles survivable, perhaps even endurable. Evoking his deeply divided character, his character flaws, his woes, his serious despair, he wishes "literature to appease human loneliness, yet not anything can assuage human loneliness.

Additional info for The Bow and the Lyre: A Platonic Reading of the Odyssey

Show sample text content

Eurycleia has her personal ranking to settle, simply as Telemachus has (22. 462–64). He claims that the slaves had insulted him besides, notwithstanding we haven't heard whatever approximately it (cf. 22. 426–27), and comes to a decision to disobey his father and provides them an unclean loss of life, no longer by means of sword, as Odysseus had ordered, yet through placing. Odysseus’s contemptuous connection with Aphrodite makes Telemachus’s disobedience all yet inevitable (22. 444–45). That Odysseus expected his disobedience wouldn't shock an individual. Telemachus will get his palms soiled and joins within the punishment of Melanthius.

At its head are the entire princes of his empire, yet at the back of them, ready carefully for the result, are all those that don't take into accout the goodness of his rule and feature the lack of their family members and of the booty they'd have introduced again with them to feed their anger. That Odysseus waits till the final minute to recruit Eumaeus and Philoitius indicates how reluctant he's to set up Telemachus’s rule with such allies. they need to be paid for his or her loyalty, and Melanthius is the associated fee. 203 the hot order Odysseus permits to shape at the back of his again, as though it weren't of his personal doing, doesn't simply contain a elevating up of Eumaeus and Philoitius but additionally a reducing of Telemachus.

Instantly after Odysseus’s story, which, Homer says, was once fake yet just like the fact, he studies that Penelope on listening to it used to be streaming tears, and her epidermis used to be melting, ‘‘just as while snow melts at the best of mountains; the East wind quickly melts it while the West wind pours down, and the rivers are complete whilst it melts; so her reasonable cheeks have been melting as she poured out tears’’ (19. 203–8). Homer juxtaposes his personal lie with Odysseus’s. Homer’s lie is within the speech; Odysseus’s is within the speaker. Homer’s lie is a picture that Homer announces in the course of the simile to be a picture and fake.

360–64). If Odysseus is to rescue Telemachus from an insupportable place, he needs to do what he does, whether he couldn't have introduced himself to hold out his destiny with out believing, as he says, that the suitors refused to honor any individual, whoever got here to them, base at the very least noble, and because of their reckless wickedness they met their unseemly destiny (22. 414–16). He definitely doesn't think, as a minimum, as Penelope does, that there by no means but were any males as evidently depraved and insolent because the suitors (17.

He used to be ready, which will accomplish this, to put waste to at least one of the towns he governed; ‘‘and not anything else might have separated us, in friendship and enjoyment, till the black cloud of dying enveloped us; however the god himself, who denied to him on my own a go back, was once doubtless green with envy of all this’’ (4. 178–82). The informal ruthlessness Menelaus provides voice to astonishes; yet each person who hears him should have been thankful that Zeus annoyed his will. Zeus himself couldn't have given a greater instance of the way males, even if their evil plans fail, are unaware of their very own wickedness and label as evil the great he prompted.

Download PDF sample

Rated 4.30 of 5 – based on 21 votes